Primary U-M Faculty Mentor. Michelle Bellino, Associate Professor, School of Education
Additional Collaborators. Drs. Julia Paulson and Robin Shields (Bristol University)
Country of Focus. Colombia
Description of the Research Project. This project centers on enhancing young people’s wellbeing as conceived through the lens of human development, recognizing the complex, multidirectional relationship between health and education. Physical and mental health are prerequisites for learning, meanwhile, more years of high-quality education are correlated with longer, healthier lives (Hahn & Truman, 2015). The UN’s Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) articulate the interdependent nature of education and other contributors to positive development, positioning education as both a contributor to positive development, and an outcome of development. SDG 4.7 advocates for all states to commit to implementing quality education, ensuring that students have opportunities to learn “the knowledge and skills needed to promote sustainable development, including among others through education for sustainable development and sustainable lifestyles, human rights, gender equality, promotion of a culture of peace and non-violence, global citizenship, and appreciation of cultural diversity and of culture’s contribution to sustainable development.” This global vision for education extends beyond academic learning and outcomes. Global citizenship, coexistence, and peace education are central to the commitments embedded in the SDGs, imagining a future in which all humans can live well, in peace with one another and the environment.
As Colombia transitions from more than fifty years of internal armed conflict, how will young people learn about the complex causes and consequences of protracted violence, and the fragile transition to peace? Negotiating an end to the conflict has polarized society, raising questions about security, accountability for past violence, and the potential for far-left and far-right political ideologies to divide Colombia’s democracy (Gomez-Suarez, 2017). Armed conflict has long impacted Colombia’s education system, resulting in school-based violence and political confrontations spilling into schools (Ardila-Rey, Killen, & Brenick, 2009; Chaux, 2009; Villar-Márquez, 2010). Public schools across Bogotá vary in their composition, including in terms of socioeconomic diversity and of ethnic minorities (Afro-Caribbean descendants and indigenous groups), as well as the proportion of student victims displaced by the armed conflict. Demographic shifts have been further impacted by growing numbers of Venezuelan migrants and refugees entering Colombia and accessing public schools (R4V, 2021).
The mixed methods study for which I am seeking a CGHE summer intern draws from survey, observational, and interview data across a diverse sample of 45 secondary schools in Bogotá to examine how teachers approach conversations about peace, conflict, and justice, as well as how students experience conversations about such “charged” topics. In this stage of the analysis, we plan to examine interactions between student demographics and young people’s expressed interest in learning about the armed conflict and peace and transitional justice process in school spaces. We ask: Are teachers working in schools with high proportions of victims more or less likely to cover topics such as peace, conflict, and justice, than their colleagues working in schools with fewer victims? Are students who self-identify as victims of the conflict more or less likely to desire these conversations or to feel that they are sufficiently covered in schools? Our qualitative data allows us to complement our claims about these interactions with an exploration of the conditions that enable classroom-based conversations about violence that are sensitive to the lived experience of victim-survivors, and how and what students learn about themselves and living in peace with others.
Trauma-informed educational practice emphasizes that young people “must feel safe and connected with others in order to be neurologically, emotionally and cognitively engaged in their learning” (Howard et al., 2020, p. 7). Education can mitigate the impact of trauma relating to displacement and exposure to violent conflict, but the protective nature of school is not a given (Bellino & Williams, 2017). Educational interactions can also negatively impact young people’s health, safety, and sense of self, contributing to intergroup conflict (Bush & Saltarelli, 2000; Davies, 2004). Looking across children’s experiences with conflict, displacement, and schooling in multiple country contexts, Winthrop and Kirk (2008) found that education was linked to children’s well-being, but only when students saw themselves as engaged in meaningful learning. That is, merely attending school was not enough to help young people “cope and hope” with challenging conditions and trust in a better future (also see Mosselson et al., 2017; UNESCO, 2019). Thus, the knowledge, skills, and attitudes for engaging in inclusive, open, and respectful learning opportunities about peace, conflict, and justice are critical in supporting young people’s overall wellbeing in democratic societies (Davies, 2004; UNESCO, 2015).
In contrast to other post-conflict/ post-peace settings, there is a strong national initiative and educational policy context for Colombia’s Cátedra de Paz (CdP), a cross-curricular effort to implement peace education, as formal peace and transitional justice processes have continued to evolve (Chaux & Velazquez, 2016). Yet few studies have examined the extent to which this policy has prompted or expanded classroom-based conversations about peace, conflict, and justice. On the one hand, there are concerns that historical coverage risks retraumatizing students, negatively impacting their health and relationships to school; on the other hand, acknowledgement of historical injustice is central to societal reconciliation processes (Barkan, 2000). Lack of knowledge about the armed conflict’s history, political dimensions, and widespread impact serves to emotionally distance, divide populations, and distort understandings of armed conflict dynamics and individual and community experiences with violence (Padilla & Bermúdez, 2016; Sánchez Meertens, 2017).
This study allows us to explore the extent to which young people, including those who self-identify as victims, express an interest in addressing violent conflict, peace, and justice in formal curriculum, and the conditions required to enable open dialogue of such topics. As classrooms and communities become more diverse and complex due to insecurity and global im/migration, greater demands are placed on educators, learners, and schools to adapt. Deepening our understanding of educators’ and students’ perspectives within and across classroom contexts will inform efforts aimed at better supporting difficult conversations during times when peace and justice are topics of vital civic—and often personal—significance, and potentially a matter of safety. Peace education aims to protect the right to life and dignity, while contributing to sustainable, equitable, and just peace (Bajaj & Hantzopoulos, 2016). Knowledge about the conditions that mobilize mass violence, skills such as the ability to engage in evidence-based reasoning and nonviolent conflict-resolution, as well as socioemotional dimensions such as self-regulation are critical components of health and wellbeing, particularly in settings impacted by violence, displacement, and their legacies.
Throughout the study, we have been in dialogue with collaborators in Colombia, including the Secretaría de Educación del Distrito de Bogota, school administrators, teachers, and educational advocacy groups. We have made efforts to disseminate findings (in Spanish) to participants and those for whom this work is most relevant, and to prioritize these dissemination efforts over scholarly endeavors. At this stage, my goal is to systematically review our dataset in order to answer these important questions, situate them in scholarly literature, and contribute to research on trauma as it relates to young people’s learning, socioemotional development, and wellbeing in contexts impacted by armed conflict and displacement. A summer intern would provide support to empirically explore how educational initiatives can better respond to protracted conflict and displacement, urgent global threats to health and wellbeing, and concerns that extend beyond the context of Colombia.
Internship Activities.
- Refine hierarchical linear modeling analysis and interaction terms for existing model, testing the relationship between exposure to conflict, presence of peace education curriculum, and interest in learning about peace, conflict, and justice
- Selectively reanalyze qualitative interviews with teachers for relevant themes and data (n=46)
- Analyze selected open-ended questions for student surveys (n=3000+) in order to identify relevant data and themes
- Analyze ethnographic fieldnotes for school observations and focus group data (n=~20)
- Review methodological literature cross-nationally to explore how young people are asked about violence exposure and processes of self-identification
- Review literature on self-identification and legal registration for victims in Colombia
- Review literature on trauma in school settings as linked to curriculum coverage, particularly addressing violent pasts
- Write and respond to draft paper sections
- Draft conference abstract for Comparative and International Education Society meeting
- Prepare slides for presenting research findings and implications
- Communicate with local partners in Colombia
- Preparation of 1-3 page report in Spanish for circulation to school administrators, teachers, and Secretaría de Educación staff
Link to project. https://mjbellino.com/research/teaching-peace/
References.
Ardila-Rey, A., Killen, M., & Brenick, A. (2009). Moral Reasoning in Violent Contexts: Displaced and Non-displaced Colombian Children’s Evaluations of Moral Transgressions, Retaliation, and Reconciliation. Social Development, 18(1), 181-209.
Bajaj, M. and Hantzopoulos, M. (2016). Peace Education: International Perspectives. London: Bloomsbury.
Barkan, Elazar. 2000. The guilt of nations: Restitution and negotiating historical injustices. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Bellino, Michelle J., and James H. Williams. 2017. Introduction. In (Re)constructing memory: Education, identity, and conflict, edited by Michelle J. Bellino and James H. Williams, 1-20. Rotterdam, The Netherlands: Sense Publishers.
Bush, K.D. and Saltarelli, D. (2000). The Two Faces of Education in Ethnic Conflict: Towards a Peacebuilding Education for Children. Florence, Italy: UNICEF Innocenti Research Centre.
Chaux, E. (2009). Citizenship Competencies in the Midst of a Violent Political Conflict: The Colombian Educational Response. Harvard Educational Review 79(1), pp. 84-93.
Chaux, E., & Velásquez, A.M. (2016). Orientaciones generales para la implementación de la Cátedra de la Paz en los establecimientos educativos de preescolar, básica y media de Colombia. Bogotá: Ministerio de Educación.
Davies, L. (2004). Education and conflict: Complexity and chaos. London: Routledge.
Gomez-Suarez, A. (2017). Peace Process Pedagogy: Lessons from the no-vote victory in the Colombian Peace Referendum. Comparative Education, 53(3), 462-482.
Hahn, Robert A. & Truman, Benedict I. (2015). Education Improves Public Health and Promotes Health Equity. International Journal of Health Services 2015; 45(4), pp. 657–678. DOI: 10.1177/0020731415585986
Howard, Patrick, Michael Corbett, Andrea Burke-Saulnier, and David Young. 2020. "Education futures: Conservation and change." Background paper for the Futures of Education initiative.
Mosselson, J., Morshed, M. M., & Changamire, N. (2017). Education and Wellbeing for Refugee Youth. Peace Review, 29(1), 15-23.
Padilla, A. L., & Bermúdez, A. N. (2016). Normalising conflict and de-normalising violence: Challenges and possibilities of critical teaching of the history of the Colombian armed conflict. Revista Colombiana de Educación, 71(1), 187-218.
(R4V) Inter-agency Coordination Platform for Refugees and Migrants from Venezuela. (2021). Regional Refugee and Migrant Response Plan, January - December 2021.
Sánchez Meertens, A. (2017). Los saberes de la guerra: Memoria y conocimiento intergeneracional del conflicto en Colombia: Siglo del Hombre Editores S.A.
UNESCO. (2019). Education as healing: Addressing the trauma of displacement through social and emotional learning [Policy Paper 38].
Villar-Márquez, E. (2010). School-Based Violence in Colombia: Links to State-Level Armed Conflict, Educational Effects and Challenges. Background paper prepared for the Education for All Global Monitoring Report 2011, The hidden crisis: Armed conflict and education. London, UK: Overseas Development Institute.
Winthrop, Rebecca, and Jackie Kirk. (2008). Learning for a Bright Future: Schooling, Armed Conflict, and Children’s Well‐Being." Comparative Education Review 52 (4): 639-661.